Two town-owned lots in downtown Waxhaw could become a three-story building with a steakhouse or similar restaurant and an indoor play space for children. Or the accountant whose office is across the street could buy them, keep the Broome Street building for offices and a café, and turn the Church Street lot into parking. Commissioners want to hear more from both, and the bid that scored higher offers the town $130,000 less.
The Board of Commissioners took no vote on the lots at its work session on Tuesday, Nov. 17. Scored by the mayor and the five commissioners, Mindy A. Distante's bid averaged 79.83 out of 100 and Estifanos Development's 77.17, Business Development Director Alara Baltmiskis told the board. Price falls under one of the six criteria, financial feasibility and acquisition terms. The others are fit with the downtown vision, concept and design, economic and community impact, experience and ability to deliver, and public benefit. The scores do not automatically decide which proposal the town prefers or commit it to a sale, she said.
Distante offered $325,000 in cash for both lots, at 321 N. Broome St. and 316 N. Church St. She would keep the Broome Street building for her firm's offices, an entrepreneur center called BizLab and a café, with a plaza open to the public. The Church Street building and a garage would come down for a parking lot, which staff estimated could hold 22 to 26 spaces. Her proposal projects keeping five jobs at her firm and adding 14 at the firm and BizLab, with the work done 18 to 24 months after closing. Her husband, Mark Distante, has commercial construction experience, it says.
Estifanos Development offered $455,000 for both lots. The company is led by Estifanos Mihtsentu, who founded Jebena Cafe next door on North Church Street. Its plan puts a steakhouse or similar restaurant and an indoor family play space on the ground floor of a three-story building, with offices above, a courtyard and about 28 parking spaces. It would look at reusing the 1940 building on Church Street. The plan works on the two town lots alone, the company says, and the Jebena Cafe lot could join later.
The company estimates the project would cost $11 million to $15 million and bring about 100 to 120 jobs. It would borrow about 60% to 65% of the cost from a regional bank or community lender, with the rest coming from its principal and partners, and it asks for no town money. It also offers to finish within five years or give the land back to the town.
Ripple Effect Partners, whose partners include Marc and Oana Graveline, Waxhaw residents who founded Carefree Boat Club Charlotte, averaged 71.83. It offered $160,000 for the Broome Street lot alone and planned to spend about $270,000 turning the building into two office suites. Mayor Pro Tem Susanna Wedra said she scored it lower because it covered only one lot.
Commissioner Richard Daunt called the three plans small, medium and large. "Estifanos would be my ideal because it's just so big and would make such a big difference," he said. Wedra said she wants more retail and "jobs that possibly teens could work at."
Mayor Robert J. Murray III said the Estifanos plan "seemed too good to be true," and that his score for it "suffered mainly from a clarity standpoint and a confidence standpoint." He also said it "hits all the right notes." Later in the discussion, Daunt said, "maybe the Distante inherently has more certainty just because it's not so ambitious."
Wedra asked how the town would make sure "we didn't sell a pretty good asset and then not have it redeveloped in a timely fashion." Town Attorney Matt Dellinger said a sale can include a clause that returns the land to the town if the buyer does not build what it promised.
Members want to know how the two finalists would pay for their plans and what they have built before. Dellinger suggested the board pick a couple of its members to meet with them, and no one was named that night. All three proposals are in the town's agenda packet.
Kensington Drive
The town opened three bids on Nov. 17 for improvements to Kensington Drive between N.C. 16 and Connell's Point Avenue, and staff plans to bring a contract recommendation to the board on Dec. 8, Assistant Town Engineer James Kelly said. If the board approves and the N.C. Department of Transportation agrees, staff hopes to start construction early next year.
